Experts Weigh In On The Best And Worst Dog Food Brands

Making sure your dog is eating the right food is one of the most important things owners can do. While some dog food brands provide plenty of healthy nutrients, others fall short and could leave your dog feeling sick. We've gathered the reviews from experts, and you might be surprised by what you learn!

Best: Instinct Original Grain-Free Dry

the front of a bag of instinct original grain-free dry
Instinct
Instinct

Dog Food Advisor gave Instinct Original Grain-Free dry food five out of five stars. They use healthy ingredients such as beef, chicken meal, white fish meal, peas, and chicken fat.

It comes in several varieties including beef, chicken, duck, salmon, and more. This brand is great for dogs who tend to be a little picky when it comes to their food and doesn't include harmful additives.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Ol' Roy Complete Nutrition

ADVERTISEMENT
ol' roy complete nutrition dog food bag
Ol' Roy
Ol' Roy
ADVERTISEMENT

According to Pet Worshiper, Ol' Roy Complete Nutrition dog food received a rating of 3.2 out of 10. The brand puts cheap fillers in the recipe including wheat, corn, and soy.

ADVERTISEMENT

There are also several meat by-products and artificial ingredients that are used to try and give it a better flavor. These unhealthy ingredients are used in order for it to be made and sold at a cheaper price.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Canidae Grain-Free Pure Dry Dog Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
canidae grain-free pure dry dog food front of bag
Canidae
Canidae
ADVERTISEMENT

With ingredients such as salmon, sweet potatoes, and peas, Canidae Grain-Free Pure dog food received five out of five stars on Dog Food Advisor.

ADVERTISEMENT

While it is a bit pricey, it comes in a wide variety of flavors including salmon, bison, lamb, duck, and more. Canidae has a ton of protein and is free of ingredients that disrupt digestion such as corn, wheat, and soy.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Purina Dog Chow Complete Adult With Real Chicken

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
purina dog chow complete adult with real chicken dog food bag
Purina
Purina
ADVERTISEMENT

When looking for a healthy dog food brand, one of the first things you should do is check the ingredients. Purina Dog Chow Complete Adult with Real Chicken doesn't have the greatest recipe.

ADVERTISEMENT

The first ingredient is grain corn, which is hard for many dogs to digest. They also use a lot of bone meal, which causes constipation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Nature's Logic Dry Dog Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
nature's logic dry dog food with canine chicken meal
Nature's Logic
Nature's Logic
ADVERTISEMENT

Nature's Logic dry dog food received five out of five stars from the experts at Dog Food Advisor. Its food is packed with nutritious ingredients in each of its meals including chicken meal, millet, pumpkin seed, and yeast culture.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you want to add some variety to your dog's food, owners can pick from several different flavors including duck, lamb, turkey, sardine, rabbit, pork, and beef.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Gravy Train

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
gravy train beefy classic dog food bag
Gravy Train
Gravy Train
ADVERTISEMENT

With a name like Gravy Train, it shouldn't be too difficult to tell that this brand is one of the worst foods for dogs.

ADVERTISEMENT

They use a substantial amount of meat by-products, compared to real meat. Also, there are high levels of soy, cornstarch, and artificial colorings and preservatives in the ingredients.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Hill's Science Diet Dry Dog Food Sensitive Stomach & Skin

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
hill's science diet dry dog food sensitive stomach and skin bag
Hill's
Hill's
ADVERTISEMENT

Diet can affect the overall health of your dog, so feeding them the proper food can make a huge difference. Veterinarians interviewed by New York Magazine agreed that Hill's Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin was a good choice.

ADVERTISEMENT

It helps dogs manage their weight, makes digestion a lot easier and stops unwanted itching.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Twin Pet Adult Dog Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
twin pet adult dog dry food front of bag
Twin Pet
Twin Pet
ADVERTISEMENT

The first ingredient of Twin Pet Adult dog food should be a warning sign for owners. Ground corn is listed at the top and contains a lot of carbohydrates.

ADVERTISEMENT

Wheat middlings is the next ingredient, which is a by-product from processed cereals and has almost no nutritional value. Twin Pet also has high amounts of sodium and preservatives.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Royal Canin Small Adult Dry Formula

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
royal-canin
Royal Canin/Matt Cardy/Getty Images
Royal Canin/Matt Cardy/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

New York Magazine surveyed 13 veterinarians to ask which dog food is the best and at least eight said Royal Canin Small Adult Dry Formula dog food.

ADVERTISEMENT

Royal Canin conducts research, feeding trials, and more to make sure dogs will benefit from their food. It also found dogs tend to like the flavor of its food more than other brands.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Kal Kan Complete Adult

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
kal kan complete adult dog food bag
Kal Kan
Kal Kan
ADVERTISEMENT

Corn happens to be the first ingredient used in Kal Kan Complete Adult dog food. The grain messes with digestion, isn't nutritious, and can sometimes bring in chemicals used when the corn was harvesting.

ADVERTISEMENT

The next ingredient is bone meal, which is essentially ground-up animal bones and cartilage. Other fillers such as soybean meal and wheat are used as well.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Stella & Chewy's Dinner Patties

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
stella & chewy's dinner patties front of bag
Stella & Chewy's
Stella & Chewy's
ADVERTISEMENT

New York Magazine asked veterinarians what the best raw dog food brand was and they responded with Stella & Chewy's Dinner Patties. Owners should beware that raw dog food can be dangerous, so it's crucial to find the right brands-- Stella passes the test!

ADVERTISEMENT

Raw food actually has a lot of nutritional benefits including improved digestion, boosted immune system, reduced inflammation, and allergy relief.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: IAMS Proactive Health Minichunks Adult

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
iams proactive health minichunks dog food bag
IAMS
IAMS
ADVERTISEMENT

Try not to get too disgusted with the ingredients found in IAMS Proactive Health Minichunks Adult dog food. They use chicken by-product, which is the remains of slaughtered chickens that aren't used by humans.

ADVERTISEMENT

This brand is known to irritate allergies in dogs and also includes synthetic protein and corn.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Orijen Dry Dog Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
orijen original dry dog food
Orijen
Orijen
ADVERTISEMENT

One reviewer who gave their dog Origen dry dog food said, "Since he's been on it his coat looks much better, he has more energy, and goes to the bathroom on a regular basis."

ADVERTISEMENT

Orijen uses natural ingredients including deboned chicken, deboned turkey, Atlantic flounder, cage-free eggs, and whole Atlantic mackerel.

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Pedigree Adult Complete Nutrition

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pedigree
Pedigree/Mike Thomas/Express Newspapers/Getty Images
Pedigree/Mike Thomas/Express Newspapers/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

According to Alpha Paw, owners reported that their dogs vomited and had intestinal troubles after consuming Pedigree Adult Complete Nutrition dog food.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pedigree confirmed that their kibble actually has pig hair. It should also be alarming that their first ingredient is ground whole grain corn, which usually disrupts dogs' digestion.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Merrick Classic Healthy Grains

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
merrick classic healthy grains dog food bag
Merrick
Merrick
ADVERTISEMENT

The ingredients found in Merrick Classic Healthy Grains dry dog food are all-natural and nutritious. These include deboned beef, deboned chicken, oatmeal, barley, brown rice, pork meal, and more.

ADVERTISEMENT

One reviewer wrote, "I switched over to Merrick and within weeks noticed a change in weight and energy in all my pets."

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Cesar Filets

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
cesar-food
Cesar/Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Cesar/Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Don't let the cute dog on the Cesar filets dish fool you. While these may seem appetizing for dogs, they are one of the worst options.

ADVERTISEMENT

This brand is known for having a ton of unnecessary salt in their food, which is bad for all dogs' health. Also, there are more meat by-products than actual meat.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Annamaet Ultra

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
annamaet ultra dry dog food bag
Annamaet
Annamaet
ADVERTISEMENT

Dogs of all ages will be able to enjoy Annamaet Ultra dry dog food. Their recipes come in chicken meal and brown rice, salmon, and more and include many healthy ingredients.

ADVERTISEMENT

One owner replied, "I only started feeding this food a few months ago after extensive research and I couldn't be happier with the results. Beautiful long, thick coats, firm, small bowel movements, and great accessible energy."

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Kibbles 'N Bits

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
kibbles
Kibbles 'n Bits/Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
Kibbles 'n Bits/Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Kibble is one of the worst foods for dogs, so Kibbles n' Bits ranks as one of the unhealthiest dog food brands.

ADVERTISEMENT

The top ingredient in Kibbles 'n Bits is corn, which is rough on digestion with no nutritional value. It also uses meat by-products, synthetic food colorings, preservatives, and more.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Dr. Tim's

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
dr. tim's dry dog food bag
Dr. Tim's
Dr. Tim's
ADVERTISEMENT

Dog Food Advisor gave Dr. Tim's dog food five out of five stars. This brand is affordable and contains nutritious ingredients including chicken meal, brown rice, dried beet pulp, and whole oat groats.

ADVERTISEMENT

After one reviewer fed it to their dog they wrote, "He has done extremely well on this food and it has eliminated his gas/hard stool issues entirely."

ADVERTISEMENT

Worst: Great Choice Adult Complete Nutrition

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
great choice adult complete nutrition dog food bag
Great Choice
Great Choice
ADVERTISEMENT

It won't be a great choice if owners feed their dogs Great Choice Adult Complete Nutrition dog food. The ingredients are what you would find in lower quality dog food including corn, wheat, and meat by-products.

ADVERTISEMENT

There are tons of fillers, additives, artificial colors, flavors, preservatives, and more, which can be detrimental to the health of your dog.

ADVERTISEMENT

Best: Redbarn Grain Free Dry Dog Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Redbarn
Redbarn
ADVERTISEMENT

For those who want to keep their doggos grain-free, Redbarn's option is a great choice. Dog Food Advisor notes that it gets most of its meat protein from turkey and chicken, which also make up its first two ingredients.

ADVERTISEMENT

It also has a fat-to-protein ratio of 55 percent or so, making it a healthy choice for your pup.

ADVERTISEMENT

WORST: Sportmix

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Sportmix
Sportmix
ADVERTISEMENT

The name and label promises some kind of active nutrition for sporty dogs, and the ingredients show that it's a low-quality product that should probably be available.

ADVERTISEMENT

The main ingredients in most types of Sportmix are fillers like corn that do little to improve a dog's nutrition. It's a reminder to always double-check the ingredients.

ADVERTISEMENT

BEST: The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Dehydrated

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
The Honest Kitchen
The Honest Kitchen
ADVERTISEMENT

Dehydrated food is a great option for older dogs, or dogs with dental problems, because it's easier to chew and digest than standard kibble.

ADVERTISEMENT

NY Mag ranks this offering from The Honest Kitchen highly because it's far less processed than competing brands, even noting that it almost looks like human food (no, we wouldn't recommend trying it yourself).

ADVERTISEMENT

WORST: Skinner's Working Dog

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Skinner's Working Dog
Skinner's Working Dog
ADVERTISEMENT

Working dogs should need good nutrition, but this lineup from Skinner's leaves a lot to be desired. Like many of the culprits on this list, Skinner's just doesn't cut it when it comes to ingredient quality.

ADVERTISEMENT

A review on The Pet Quarter, a U.K. website, slams this brand for being filled with "copious" amounts of refined carbs.

ADVERTISEMENT

BEST: The Farmer's Dog

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
The Farmer's Dog
The Farmer's Dog
ADVERTISEMENT

Subscription services aren't for everyone, but just think of this as Chef's Plate for your dog. NBC quotes a veterinarian who praises The Farmer's Dog for its palatability and popularity.

ADVERTISEMENT

"If you're on a budget and have a large dog, this might not be a cost-effective option for you, but it may be more beneficial for owners of smaller dogs," she says.

ADVERTISEMENT

WORST: Beneful

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Beneful
Beneful
ADVERTISEMENT

Beneful is a smaller brand under the Purina umbrella, and just like Purina, it's probably best to avoid if you want the best quality food for your dog.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Pet MD Animal Hospital points out that Beneful contains "unnecessary and unnatural additives" such as artificial colorings - kind of ludicrous, considering your dog can't even see these colors.

ADVERTISEMENT

BEST: Freshpet refrigerated

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Freshpet
Freshpet
ADVERTISEMENT

Do you ever wonder about how many preservatives and junk must be in dog food to keep it shelf-stable? This offering from Freshpet needs refrigeration, because it's made with legitimately human-grade ingredients.

ADVERTISEMENT

This one wins high marks for only containing whole meat, not meat-meal. It's also a good option for doggos who are more picky.

ADVERTISEMENT

WORST: Twin Pet

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Twin Pet
Twin Pet
ADVERTISEMENT

This low-cost brand can sometimes be found at Walmart and other big box retailers, but if you check out the ingredients, you'll realize it should just be left on the shelf.

ADVERTISEMENT

Twin Pet is doubly bad, because it not only contains too much corn filler and wheat middlings, but also meat byproducts that aren't great for dogs.

ADVERTISEMENT

BEST: Wellness Natural Pet Food

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Wellness Pet Food
Wellness Pet Food
ADVERTISEMENT

Dogs have allergies too, but not many brands of dog food cater to them. Wellness is an outlier, and manages to cut out some of the most common allergens like grains and certain proteins.

ADVERTISEMENT

This brand also contains lots of salmon, which contains omega fatty acids that are good with keeping skin inflammation under control.

ADVERTISEMENT

WORST: Natural Balance

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Natural Balance
Natural Balance
ADVERTISEMENT

Any product that over-emphasizes the concept of nature or being natural should be viewed with some skepticism, and Natural Balance dog food fits into this category.

ADVERTISEMENT

Less than 20 percent of its calories come from protein, meaning that you'll be feeding your dog a lot of processed carbs, leaving them hungry and unsatisfied.